Good morning guys!
Boy, do I love an active thread!
Katie,
I wasn't aware of that reality about crystals and gemstones. It's amazing how often we look the other way, or are just assume that things are done the "right" way when in fact, when you bother to scratch the surface and look underneath, some ugly facts start emerging... I'll never look at crystals the same way again. And, may I say, I find your attitude very inspiring. When I think about it, the rocks, acorn and pebbles I have collected during trips are far more meaningful to me than the crystals I bought in a shop for their lithotherapeutic properties. And, if I actually bothered to "feel" them and interact with them while transcending their emotional significance, I might find out more about what lithotherapeutic properties they have. Wow... thank you for that wonderful gift, Katie! (btw, still living in greasyland, but it's definitely stabilizing....!) Ahem how about I trade some small red rocks from the Broceliande forest for a couple of Lake Bala pebbles?
Art,
LOL yeah, excommunication would not be worth it!

You raised very interesting points and now I'm curious and eager to know more, so I pmed you the rest of this post!
Treegod,
Isaac Bonewits' conference on druidcast was absolutely loaded with useful info. I've been working for days, translating it for the Sabbat committee at the boutique so they can learn from it too. I've also ordered his book about public rituals. I love his distinction between paleo-meso-neo, hence my comment that everything we do today is neo, no choice. I would love you to tell me more about your conception of Ecosophy and Ecopsychology. There is a wonderful, wonderful podcast about this on itunes. It's about working with animal spirits in therapy; I'll give you the link if you want (I don't have iTunes at work...)
Frog,
Great to feel backed up, thank you for that!

I'm trying to determine what difference she sees indeed. One way of looking at it is comparing what they do in public rituals at ADF for example. They work with the Well, the Fire and the Tree. It's absolutely central to the rituals... OBOD rituals do adress those things, but way more subtly. If you go in the ritual section of the White Oak website, you can see that the ritual behavior is very, very strict and does feel like it was inspired by old sources (you MUST light your sacred fire with a crystal and the sun, for example). I can easily see how OBOD rituals seem more... hippie, in comparison. I have yet to hear about the Three Cauldrons in the gwersi; I know that concept is central in traditional approaches of druidry. The person in charge of the workshops said that she has been to neodruidic rituals and people were doing literally the opposite of what she had been taught in what she calls "traditional druidism". OBOD teaches us to enter the Circle through the West... I think other traditions who claim to be more "traditional" would tell you to enter through the East. She doesn't want the workshop attendees to be confused (they are almost all beginners who only know Wicca), hence why she insists on making the distinction. And indeed... during our public ritual at Beltane, there was a small confusion about where the North-South axis was in the temple, and several attendees were
deeply upset because technically, the Directions had not been called properly. Beginners, especially when they only know the very structured Wicca, are easily perturbed by "contradictions" like this. Even if you explain, over and over, that there are no Directions in the astral and ethereal planes...
I was very surprised by the strict attitude of the person who wrote the page you linked. According to that source, we absolutely can't be Wiccan, or Buddhist, or Catholic, and be a Druid at the same time. Gee, even Bonewits, in his approach of druidism vs druidry, would disagree with that I think!

Do you agree with the contents of that page?
Darc,
Oh, thanks for the links!!!!

Those are wonderful topics and I'm all excited because, although my husband is an atheist who is not interested in spirituality, we are mindful about our ecological footprint, and those topics will probably interest him. It will be fascinating to deepen my knowledge of these approaches and discuss them with him. And fellow druids of course!
Okay that's all for now! Take care people!
Morgane